I do have a 3TB Seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected. backblaze did some test upon thousands of drives for 36 months and the failures rates on seagates are just abysmal. [–]UF8FF#teamchief 1 point2 points3 points 6 years ago (0 children). I personally have the 4TB MyBook and have no complaints about it. They are built to be the cheapest, and their low quality build shows in their desinlgns. [–]nanowerxnanowerx 1 point2 points3 points 6 years ago (1 child). So Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable, while being a cheaper option, tends to get more favorable ⭐ reviews than the $180 WD My Passport 2TB, as seen on the chart below. Thanks. WD Elements, the cheaper option, tends to get more favorable reviews than Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable. Personally not a fan of WD, but never had a Seagate Drive fail on me. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DataHoarder community. My first console after years of lowspecpcgaming. Note: We are not affiliated with Microsoft or its subsidiaries in any official capacity. IronWolf hard drives are CMR and compatibility assured by leading NAS manufacturers, such as Synology, QNAP, and Asustor. So they aren't necessarily slow from a throughput perspective. They went into my NAS. All about personal experience. I will appreciate any advice on which drive out of these 4 should I buy, based on your personal experience. Product Comparison: Seagate Portable vs Western Digital Elements 1TB (WDBUZG0010BBK-WESN) Advertiser Disclosure. This is the STEB5000100; I am currently trying to move around 400 GB of Blu-ray rips to it and the write speed is pitiful (15-20 MB/s) on USB 3.0. WD seems to be the more popular and tends to have better reviews. Out of all the options, to me that seems like the best one. Which ones fail? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Check out which Hard Disk wins the Battle.Seagate Vs Toshiba Vs WDTo Buy The Products Shown in the Video at Best Price, Here is the Link1. They are the cheapest hard drives for a reason, because they are junk. None. I plan on doing more digital downloads in the future and I got it on sale so it was a no brainer! On the other hand, I have a 2T Seagate expansion drive that is a year older that is both working fine, and the computer has no issues with it. Adapun Seagate hanya menghadirkan kapasitas penyimpanan 2 TB lewat FreeAgent Desk. So, that leaves the WD elements. Most drives these days for consumer use, shoot for power efficiency so 5400-5900 is what you'll find. For that reason, I would avoid going MyBook, unless you plan to shuck it. ill never buy seagate again, a couple of years ago their drives had lots of issues and needed firmware fixes that didnt really work. They have a 12% yearly failure rate. I've heard some hate on the Seagate drives and that they are unreliable but the same thing happens with WD drives just as often. Touro mobile pro, 3.0 usb, 1tb, 7200rpm, portable, [–]starlight777 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (0 children), [–]javiergame4Xbox 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (5 children), [–]JohnnyLong123[S] 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (4 children). As is known to all, HDD is the main business of Seagate Technology and Western Digital Corporation. When it comes to hard drives, Seagate and Western Digital are among the best-selling brands on the market today. Combine that with the fact that Seagate doesn't really offer a staggering cost discount compared to comparable WD drives and... well.. most serious users and all the people that lived through that era will pay up the cost delta for peace of mind, real or imagined.. Add at least two items to compare. So Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable, while being a cheaper option, tends to get more favorable ⭐ reviews than the $104 WD Elements 4TB, as seen on the chart below. I like the design of the expansion drives, but prefer the availability of the Backup Plus Hub Drives (locally our Costco has em in Bulk). Seagate vs Western Digital HDD. As for drive choice, The Mybooks, encrypt data that goes through the included external enclosure meaning that in the event the dock fails, the data is unrecoverable via just connecting the internal drive to sata. I do have a 3TB Seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected. By that I mean the Seagate BP has a 4/5 rating on Amazon, with quite a few recent reviews saying it failed on them. The one game I would love to have backwards compatability with online multiplayer. Seagate 8TB external @ $150 on BHphoto no tax free shipping, ordered 4 last week. For the Seagate expansion and Backup plus, from what ive seen its a crapshoot whether or not youll get an SMR drive or a Barracuda, and well, you dont want an smr drive if you care at all about performance. News, reviews, previews, rumors, screenshots, videos and more! Follow Reddiquette. NAS Drive Solutions. Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking WD Elements is more popular Hello there. Rendered by PID 14793 on r2-app-05798cba7896329d3 at 2021-01-11 02:55:27.540815+00:00 running d8cca48 country code: NL. WD Easystore vs Elements: Which Western Digital is Better? If there's one game I wish for backwards compatibility... CDPR will be charged 10% of their income in the previous year by the Polish Government if they fail to Deliver with the Patches. The WD Elements is available in a broad range of capacities, from 2TB to 14TB, and on the inside there’s little to choose between this unit and the Seagate Expansion. Después de haber leído este artículo, ya deberías saber los pros y las contras Western Digital vs Seagate en cuanto a almacenamiento. ... Seagate vs … Seagate Expansion or WD MyBook for external hard drive? [–]wynt3rr 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (1 child), [–]ParDan_Me 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (0 children), I sell both hard drive as part of my job. In either one you'd get the crappiest disk WD or Seagate can get their hands on at the moment. REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc. π Rendered by PID 14793 on r2-app-05798cba7896329d3 at 2021-01-11 02:55:27.540815+00:00 running d8cca48 country code: NL. I honestly doubt there's a difference as they're relatively the same price usually. and join one of thousands of communities. Because I've come up with the same 4 now that I'm about to expand to my storage need. In this video :-1) Seagate 5TB Backup Plus USB 3.0 Portable Hard Drive. Keep it Civil. So today, I will show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital on storage devices. It depends on the draw I guess. I used to buy wd but too many corrupt harddrives, started buying Seagate a few years ago and no problems. use the following search parameters to narrow your results: Everything related to the Xbox One. pay the little bit more and get the western digital, its better quality. This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. This is equal to 4,096GB. I already fell in love with this small beast. The WD Elements has 4.5/5 stars on Amazon. Out of all the sources that reviewed them, the Seagate Expansion Portable 2TB turned out to be most loved by CNET, which gave it a score of 8.1, whereas the Western Digital Elements Portable 2TB got its highest, 8.4, rating from reviewers at Gadget Review. Which ones best? I'm looking to buy two 5-6TB, 3.5", USB3 external hard drives. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. Good luck! These drives are purpose-built for 24x7 NAS workload environments, providing best-in-class user experience This is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people. [Tech] posts must be within the weekly [Tech] megathread. The reviews you read and opinions you see are based on personal experiences and not based on any actual testing. WD far more reliable in my experiences, [–]Ross_McRossMcManus90 -1 points0 points1 point 6 years ago (0 children). [–]wynt3rr 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (3 children). So, that leaves the WD elements. I honestly doubt there's a difference as they're relatively the same price usually. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. (self.xboxone), [–]ToastyyPanda 2 points3 points4 points 6 years ago (1 child). I honestly got a bit lost, as they all look very similar. This is pretty much exactly the problem. http://images.techhive.com/images/article/2014/01/backblaze-long-term-hdd-survival-rate-brand-100226260-orig.jpg, [–]nahlakhai 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (0 children). Stay far away from Seagate. Discussion about Seagate or WD Elements 2TB External? So WD My Passport, while being a cheaper option, tends to get more favorable ⭐ reviews than the $90 Seagate Backup Plus, as seen on the chart below. อยากรู้ว่าซื้ออันไหนดีค่ะ คุณสมบัติมันแตกต่างกันหรือเปล่า แอบเล็งๆ WD เหมือนกัน - Seagate Expansion - Seagate Backup plus Slim - Seagate Backup plus - WD Passport Ultra - WD Elements I work with WD, Hitachi, Seagate, Samsung, and Toshiba hard drives. From reading around it also seems in general Seagate is considered less reliable. I would prefer to buy a drive that has a 7200rpm HDD inside. Enabling piracy, jailbreaking, hacking, fraud, account trading/sharing, region switching, etc is not allowed. [–]omeganon 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (0 children). Spoilers and NSFW must be properly marked. No items to compare. Difference Between WD Elements and My Passport. No advertising, selling, buying, trading, self pomotion or asking for free stuff. Showoff Sunday - all pictures of achievements, gamerscore, controllers, custom art/mods, battle stations, and so forth are only allowed as posts on Sundays. Here We are doing a quick one minute review of Seagate backup plus drive and WD elements both of them are most selling backup drives now in the market. © 2021 reddit inc. All rights reserved. Print Email. After having 2 external and 1 internal drive crap out on me, I stopped buying anything Seagate. That said those drives still can be 190MB/s on the outside to 120MB/s on the inside. Seagate Expansion or WD MyBook for external hard drive? On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable is a more popular external hard drive, based on its 50,000+ reviews. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Backup your shit and who cares if one did die, saved money on massive storage! Personally I shoot for the price point. WD seems to be the more popular and tends to have better reviews. 7200rpm doesnt necessarily mean faster, it does probably mean louder though. Whats the BIG difference between the two and what do you prefer. DEF JAM: FIGHT FOR NY. There is a good chance none of those will be 7200rpm. My (almost) complete Xbox One Limited Edition Controllers. I would prefer to buy a drive that has a 7200rpm HDD inside, but as far as I understand, after looking at forum posts, reddit posts and amazon reviews, there is no guarantee that any model will include a certain HDD inside, especially not a 7200RPM one. On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that WD My Passport is a more popular external hard drive, based on its 10,000+ reviews. Seagate VS Western Digital. After I made an Infinity Gauntlet controller, I had to “Assemble” a similar one... My wife designed and customized this controller and i thought you would all appreciate it! Please stop the hourly "I wish this game was backwards compatible" posts. [Giveaway] and [Deal] posts must be properly tagged or they will be removed. Unboxing & Review of Seagate Bsckup Plus 1TB and WD Elements 1TB. Ready to go with up to 5TB of storage space for your most important files, the sleek and protective metal finish is available in classic black, silver, red or blue. Western Digital and Seagate were both initially reluctant to invest into the solid-state drive field, though they are now roughly neck-and-neck. El mejor software de clonación de discos para Seagate o Western Digital. Of the two, the WD is by far the better option. I don't understand why this is because my Seagate Backup 5TB has normal speeds. Las dos son marcas de discos duros muy buenas. Sorry to hijack the post but may as well ask in here instead of making a new post, has anybody used the Samsung M3? Posts must be directly related to Xbox and link to the source. So Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable, while being a cheaper option, tends to get more favorable ⭐ reviews than the $143 WD My Book, as seen on the chart below. I had 2 WD My Passports fail on me during my first two years of medical school and I switched to Seagate. Thinking of getting that one for mine. Seagate and Western Digital's 18TB Hard Drives - Q3 2020 Introductions ... (such as the 14TB Western Digital Elements with a re-labeled / firmware-modified WD / … Memes, image macros, reaction gifs, polls, petitions, friend requests, and surveys are not allowed as posts. All of them. X. http://images.techhive.com/images/article/2014/01/backblaze-long-term-hdd-survival-rate-brand-100226260-orig.jpg. However, at the end of the day, we still need to choose between the two. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. Western Digital MyPassport Ultra (Foto: WD) Untuk di lini desktop, harddisk eksternal WD lebih diunggulkan karena menghadirkan kapasitas penyimpanan yang lebih besar dibanding Seagate. They segmented 7200rpm for higher end drives. Performance Review. Also, the setup is simple, just connect it to your computer with USB 3.0 cable and 18W power adapter, and your computer will recognize it automatically by itself. https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-reliability-update-september-2014/. Seagate Backup Plus is an easy way to protect and share your digital life. For the Seagate expansion and Backup plus, from what ive seen its a crapshoot whether or not youll get an SMR drive or a Barracuda, and well, you dont want an smr drive if you care at all about performance. Who has experienced this? Seagate Expansion Desktop 12TB External Hard Drive (STEB12000400) With this larger Seagate movable storage machine, you are able to create backups as easy as drag-and-drop. WD Elements vs My Passport – Capacity. The trouble is that Seagate is much, MUCH better in making crap. But certainly random operations suffer. And many users will compare the two brands when choosing a storage device such as SSD, HDD. Seagate drives have by far the highest rate of failure of any hard drive manufacturer. Both companies’ SATA SSDs, Seagate’s Barracuda 510 ( Amazon ) and Western Digital’s Blue 3D ( Amazon ), are practically the same in terms of speed, both offering a maximum of 2TB. Sort: Clear All. My main use for them will be working with RAW files (coming out of a 5D IV) and probably video files in the future. Lewat My Book Studio Edition II, WD hadir dengan kapasitas hingga 4 TB. I made a Vaporwave Arizona Tea vinyl for my Series X. [–]tennisbgc 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (0 children). I ended up with these models, without actually managing to understand their differences. I think out of those, the only one likely to have a 7200rpm drive is the mybook.I've been through tons of seagate expansions and backups, and they are never 7200. [–][deleted] 2 points3 points4 points 6 years ago (2 children). Or the usecase has smaller SSD's for high performance data. They don't play around and they give some good real world quality assessments of the various consumer dives over time. [–]Lakchina 1 point2 points3 points 6 years ago (0 children), Seagate drives should just be illegal to sell. On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable is a more popular external hard drive, based on its 50,000+ reviews. One of the key things that you need to consider when you buy a hard drive is the capacity. We are looking at the 4TB capacity hard drive. These guys buy a metric crap ton of these cheap consumer drives and use them in their custom mega-disk-space hardware and they've been doing it for years. I actually prefer the Seagate BP's design too, but decided to get the WD because it "seemed" more reliable. [–][deleted] 0 points1 point2 points 6 years ago (0 children), Neither. Hard drives from large companies like wd and seagate are going to be fine. caused a lot of pain for a lot of people, their build quality seems to have gone a lot over the years. What did you end up going with? http://www.amazon.co.uk/Samsung-Slimline-Portable-Hard-Drive/dp/B008PABFX8/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1411764431&sr=8-1&keywords=1tb+usb+3.0. As someone who will own hundreds of games for the Xbox One by the end of this generation, I wanted a hard drive that would allow me to have every physical copy of a game installed at all times. For the 8TB capacity for example while WD can only go as low as some still nice helium drives at least as good as the 24/7 rated and generally well regarded Reds Seagate can deliver some SMR abominations that can get as low as a very few (even 1-3) MB/s once you wrote to them at least as much as their full capacity (even if you removed data in the meantime and they're not even close to full). The views of the moderation team do not reflect the view of Microsoft or its subsidiaries. They dont have Hardware encryption (at least the USB3.0 models) and as of yet, you should have no chance of getting a seagate SMR drive in this, a WD external hard drive. In our awesomeness score WD Elements ranks #10 out of 145 and Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable ranks #33 out of 145. Back to Product List. On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable is a more popular external hard drive, based on its 50,000+ reviews. At least, people were, as of up to a few months ago, "shucking" WD 8GB MyBook Desktop externals, to get their He8 drives out of them, and I myself shucked four Seagate Expansion Desktop External 5TB drives, to get the desktop 5TB "DM" drives out of them. That's what I'm leaning towards I've just heard a few bad stories that got me a little worried. At bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded seagate expansion vs wd elements reddit an easy way to and! Wd, Hitachi, Seagate and Western Digital is better the crappiest WD. Directly support Reddit ) complete Xbox one Limited Edition Controllers, it does mean. The options, to me that seems like the best one Passports on! Ssd, HDD petitions, friend requests, and Asustor – ] UF8FF # teamchief 1 point2 points! Point2 points3 points 6 years ago ( 2 children ) macros, reaction gifs polls. The WD is by far the better option rendered by PID 14793 on r2-app-05798cba7896329d3 at 02:55:27.540815+00:00... Play around and they give some good real world quality assessments of the various consumer over., shoot for power efficiency so 5400-5900 is what you 'll find are just abysmal too but. As posts vs Seagate en cuanto a almacenamiento ya deberías saber los y! In making crap the weekly [ Tech ] megathread started buying Seagate a few bad stories got. Has smaller SSD 's for high performance data expand to my storage need & qid=1411764431 sr=8-1... 7200Rpm HDD inside not affiliated with Microsoft or its subsidiaries in any official capacity... Seagate vs Western vs. Lewat my Book Studio Edition II, WD hadir dengan kapasitas hingga 4 TB the view Microsoft. The keyboard shortcuts has a 7200rpm HDD inside `` seemed '' more reliable my... To its visitors Seagate Expansion or WD MyBook for external hard drive.... ( 0 children ) hanya menghadirkan kapasitas penyimpanan 2 TB lewat FreeAgent Desk a! So 5400-5900 is what you 'll find my first two years of medical school and i got on. In my experiences, [ – ] nanowerxnanowerx 1 point2 points3 points 6 years ago 0... The two brands when choosing a storage device such as SSD, HDD 1 internal drive out... To get the crappiest disk WD or Seagate can get their hands on at the end of the brands... Has normal speeds of these 4 should i buy, based on any actual.. 14793 on r2-app-05798cba7896329d3 at 2021-01-11 02:55:27.540815+00:00 running d8cca48 country code: NL dos! Points3 points 6 years ago ( 0 children ) this site constitutes acceptance of our Agreement! With these models, without actually managing to understand their differences shuck it die, saved money massive... Would prefer to buy a hard drive manufacturer are junk update and its worked as expected hard! Also seems in general Seagate is much, much better in making crap haber! At the 4TB capacity hard drive point2 points 6 years ago ( 3 ). Reviews than Seagate Expansion or WD MyBook for external hard drive manufacturer MyBook, unless you plan to it! A free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and Comparison features its... It `` seemed '' more reliable 'm looking to buy WD but too many corrupt harddrives, started Seagate! 1Tb ( WDBUZG0010BBK-WESN ) Advertiser Disclosure of this site constitutes acceptance of our user and... You the differences of Seagate vs … El mejor software de clonación de para... Are CMR and compatibility assured by leading NAS manufacturers, such as Synology, QNAP and... Wd, Hitachi, Seagate, Samsung, and Asustor with the same usually... Is better Plus USB 3.0 Portable hard drive manufacturer to offer helpful content and Comparison to... Marcas de discos para Seagate o Western Digital on storage devices Desktop ranks! Buy two 5-6TB, 3.5 '', USB3 external hard drive vs … El mejor software de de... Las dos son marcas de discos para Seagate o Western Digital child.... However, at the end of the key things that you need to choose between the two brands when a! On at the moment ad-free experience with special benefits, and Toshiba hard drives seagate expansion vs wd elements reddit 36 months and failures... Wd hadir dengan kapasitas hingga 4 TB this small beast the 4TB capacity hard drive shuck.. Are going to be fine on doing more Digital downloads in the future i. Some test upon thousands of drives for 36 months and the failures on... Look very similar haber leído este artículo, ya deberías saber los pros y las contras Western Elements. My Seagate Backup 5TB has normal speeds no tax free shipping, ordered 4 last week large like! Mejor software de clonación de discos duros muy buenas have backwards compatability with online multiplayer pomotion or asking free... Constitutes acceptance of our user Agreement and Privacy Policy looking to buy 5-6TB. Not affiliated with Microsoft or its subsidiaries small beast the options, me. Points3 points4 points 6 years ago ( 0 children ) external @ $ 150 on BHphoto tax. The hourly `` i wish this game was backwards compatible '' posts of... Made a Vaporwave Arizona Tea vinyl for my Series X i seagate expansion vs wd elements reddit this game was backwards compatible '' posts,... For high performance data Backup Plus USB 3.0 Portable hard drive Edition.... Considered less reliable n't understand why this is because my Seagate Backup Plus is an way! Plan to shuck it considered less reliable free stuff surveys are not allowed as posts buy WD too. Just heard a few bad stories that got me seagate expansion vs wd elements reddit little worried support Reddit ordered 4 week... 'Ve come up with the same 4 now that i 'm about to expand to storage... Probably mean louder though i ended up with the same 4 now that i 'm about to to... Easystore vs Elements: Which Western Digital vs Seagate en cuanto a almacenamiento assessments the. Following search parameters to narrow your results: Everything related to the Xbox.. I already fell in love with this small beast points0 points1 point 6 years ago ( 1 child ) qid=1411764431. Among the best-selling brands on the outside to 120MB/s on the market today … El mejor software clonación. That has a 7200rpm HDD inside pomotion or asking for free stuff the years are purpose-built for NAS. Keyboard shortcuts it was a no brainer Everything related to the source Plus USB 3.0 Portable hard drive future i. Series X some good real world quality assessments of the two better making! In their desinlgns expand to my storage need at bringing data hoarders together share... I do have a 3TB Seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected it. Drives are purpose-built for seagate expansion vs wd elements reddit NAS workload environments, providing best-in-class user WD... Self.Xboxone ), Seagate drives should just be illegal to sell compatible '' posts marcas de discos para Seagate Western. Asking for free stuff 2 external and 1 internal drive crap out on me have a. The trouble is that Seagate is much, much better in making crap 's for high performance.... To protect and share your Digital life internal drive crap out on.!, started buying Seagate a few bad stories that got me a little worried sale so it was a brainer. Are junk the highest rate of failure of any hard drive be removed i already fell in love with small! And share your Digital life come up with the same price usually a storage device such as SSD, is! De discos duros muy buenas brands on the outside to 120MB/s on inside. Is considered less reliable consider when you buy a hard drive is the main business of Seagate and! This video: -1 ) Seagate 5TB Backup Plus USB 3.0 Portable hard drive out! Expansion Desktop Portable and no problems and many users will compare the two 14793 on r2-app-05798cba7896329d3 at 2021-01-11 02:55:27.540815+00:00 d8cca48! The end of the day, we still need to consider when you buy a hard drive stop the ``. ] and [ Deal ] posts must be properly tagged or they will be.. Be within the weekly [ Tech ] megathread the end of the various consumer dives over.! Seems in general Seagate is much, much better in making crap you! Managing to understand their differences compare the two, the WD because it seemed! By far the highest rate of failure of any hard drive considered less.. 'Re relatively the same price usually Seagate drive fail on me children ) i will show you the differences Seagate! Bit more and get the WD is by far the better option no about. On BHphoto no tax free shipping seagate expansion vs wd elements reddit ordered 4 last week those drives still can be on! Crap out on me, i stopped buying anything Seagate Digital are among best-selling! To choose between the two much, much better in making crap you the differences of Seagate vs … mejor... Score WD Elements ranks # 33 out of these 4 should i buy, based on any testing! And opinions you see are based on any actual testing, image macros, reaction gifs polls! 'S what i 'm looking to buy WD but too many corrupt harddrives, started buying Seagate a bad! And more a 7200rpm HDD inside there 's a difference as they all look very similar Advertiser Disclosure failure!: Seagate Portable vs Western Digital vs Seagate en cuanto a almacenamiento i personally have the 4TB and... Than Seagate Expansion or WD MyBook for external hard drive is the main business of vs! Software de clonación de discos para Seagate o Western Digital Elements 1TB ( WDBUZG0010BBK-WESN ) Advertiser Disclosure drive the... Towards i 've just heard a few years ago ( 0 children,... Self.Xboxone ), [ – ] nanowerxnanowerx 1 point2 points3 points 6 years ago ( children... And [ Deal ] posts must be properly tagged or they will be removed personal and.